Fashion
Which Online Styling Service is Right for You?
These days, there are a plethora of online styling services that will deliver a box full of fashionable goodies right to your door. The options can be overwhelming. Should you go with a classic like Stitch Fix or one that boasts sustainable practices like Frank and Oak? Don’t know your Wantable from your Dia&Co? We’re breaking down the basics of all these clothing subscription boxes and sharing all the important factors to help you make a fashionable decision.
P.S. If you’re interested in rental clothing subscription boxes, we compare Le Tote, Rent the Runway, Gwynnie Bee and Armoire here.
Wantable vs. Frank and Oak vs. Stitch Fix vs. Dia&Co
Style Selections
Wantable
Want to find unique items from smaller brands? Whether you’re in the market for cozy classics or comfortable workout gear, this is a simple service with lots of options for women and men.
- Basic Options: You can filter your options, and go with cozy athleisure essentials and workout friendly activewear or more on-trend fashion-forward pieces for work, play, and everything in between. There’s also an option for men that includes activewear and loungewear
- Brands: Smaller brands you might not not know, but will soon adore (i.e. Liverpool, MPG Sport, Thread and Supply, Threads 4 Thoughts, etc.)
- Suitable For: Anyone! If you love to lounge in comfy clothes or want to amp up your look with some statement sweaters and cute basics that you won’t find elsewhere, this is a great option.
- Pros: Discover unique brands and find some basics you absolutely love.
- Cons: Not a lot of accessories or extras; limited brands
Frank and Oak
Want to look good and feel good on the inside? Then Frank and Oak might be the plan for you. They take their fashion and environmental footprint seriously with sustainable styles and a commitment to serving their community and the planet. The brand offers lots of transparency and boasts functionality above all else.
- Basic Options: Boxes for men and women with styles are very clean and minimalistic. There are lots of solid basics that will become staples in your wardrobe.
- Brands: Features their own signature brand
- Suitable For: Young professionals and anyone passionate about preserving the earth and social consciousness.
- Pros: Unique brand, clean aesthetic, lots of closet-filling basics. Skip a box in your plan at anytime or cancel completely with no obligation.
- Cons: Limited selection. Styling fee is applied if and when you don’t keep any item in your box.
Stitch Fix
If you love your big brands, Stitch Fix is the personal stylist subscription box service for you. With thousands of high-end collections, you can stay on trend but also remain on budget. Your stylist will work with your price limits and your persnickety style to curate the ideal options for your unique needs.
- Basic Options: Options for women, men, and kids
- Brands: Over 1,000 brands you know and love like Madewell, Sanctuary, Free People, etc., plus a few more to discover
- Suitable For: Fashion-forward individuals who are short of time and high on style.
- Pros: High quality fashion brands. You can get automatic delivery or one-time boxes with no subscription necessary. Maternity, petite and plus-size options are available, too.
- Cons: Typically, it’s just a three-day window between box receipt and expected return.
Dia&Co
Plus-size women are often forgotten about, but Dia&Co is committed to serving a community of proud and gorgeous ladies who love their bodies and love fashion. You can choose from a Style Box or an Active Box.
- Basic Options: Everyday wear plus activewear options for plus size women (sizes 14 – 32).
- Brands: A solid variety that offers versatility (i.e. Marc NY, Lauren Ralph Lauren, Rachel Rachel Roy, Cameo, Gilli, etc.)
- Suitable For: Women who embrace their bodies and want more options available to meet their curvy needs.
- Pros: Options to flatter every figure. Lots of two-way communication to help your stylist nail your aesthetic. You can also shop a la carte.
- Cons: Slightly limited range in each clothing category
How It Works
Wantable
- Choose one of three box-types: Women’s Style, Women’s Active or Men’s Edit
- Take a quick quiz so a stylist can curate the right pieces for your needs. You can also visit “The Stream” to highlight items you like to further educate your stylist, and even request specific items to be included in your “edit box” pending availability.
- Receive seven items and have five days to decide what you want to do – keep or return. Returns are free and easy via pick-up or drop-off.
Frank and Oak
- Take a quick style quiz.
- Confirm your monthly box. You can choose to skip it at any time; there is no commitment.
- You’ll get up to four items delivered to your doorstep. You have 10 days to decide what to do – keep or return. Free shipping both ways.
Stitch Fix
- Tell your stylist your size, budget and style preferences.
- Receive five items including clothing, accessories, shoes, jewelry and more.
- You have three days to decide what to do — keep or return. You are sometimes able to adjust this time frame.
Dia&Co
- Take a style quiz.
- You get five items in your box, two of which are stylist-picked and three of which you can choose if you’d like.
- You have five days to decide what to do – keep or return.
Pricing & Plans
Wantable
- Styling Fee: $20 per box, which can go towards any item you decide to keep. You’ll be credited the $20 fee if you don’t keep anything.
- Items generally range between $50 and $100 per item. The more you buy, the more you save: If you keep five or more items, you’ll get 20 percent off your total.
- Free shipping, including returns and exchanges.
Frank and Oak
- Styling Fee: $25 per box, which you only pay if you keep nothing.
- Items generally range from $29 – $149.
- Skip a month (or two!) without commitment.
- Free shipping both ways.
Stitch Fix
- Styling Fee: $20 per box. Deducted from any item you keep.
- Women’s and men’s items typically range in price from $25–$500
- Kids’ items begin at $10 each
- If and when you choose to buy everything in your delivery, you’ll receive a 25% discount off of the entire purchase.
- Free shipping both ways.
Dia&Co
- Styling Fee: $20 per box, which can go towards any item you keep.
- Most items are typically about $59 each.
- If and when you choose to buy everything in your delivery, you’ll receive a 25% discount off of the entire purchase.
- Free shipping both ways.
There you have it. A few highlights, pros, cons and distinguishing factors to help you find the subscription service that is right for you! Don’t forget to shop with Rakuten to earn Cash Back on all your stylist-selected picks.
Join The Conversation